Should i start manning or romo

Instead, Brady drove his team to a game-winning field goal with no time remaining against the then-St. Louis Rams.

The Patriots had the ball at their own 17 yard line with left and no timeouts. Of course, who knew then that Brady — in his first year as a starter playing in his first Super Bowl — would end up becoming one of the greatest quarterbacks in the history of the league. As a result, Manning nearly eclipsed 5, yards passing. While his production certainly stood out in , it was his ability to consistently take over games in pivotal stages that demonstrated his leadership to me. Manning led eight game-winning drives last season and repeatedly dug his team out of adverse situations.

That's the kind of leadership that teams expect from a franchise quarterback. Many NFL games are decided within the game's final two minutes, so the franchise quarterback must thrive in those moments. Romo has taken his share of criticism for coming up short with the game on the line, but he took steps forward in his development a season ago. He guided the Cowboys to four fourth-quarter comebacks in , and finally displayed some of the poise required to thrive in the game's definitive moments.

What was most impressive about Romo's heroics was his ability to bounce back from a poor late-game performance against the New York Jets in Week 1 to lead back-to-back fourth-quarter rallies the following two weeks. With most NFL fans clinging to the vivid memories of his spectacular failures including a botched field-goal hold against Seattle in the wild-card round , Romo must continue to deliver in the game's final stages to reverse the notion that he's a late-game goat.

Manning is about as clutch as it gets in the NFL. With five of those wins on the road, Manning certainly has the "It" factor coaches and scouts covet in a franchise signal caller.

The debate between Romo and Manning puts evaluators in a quandary when deciding whether to value raw talent and production over intangibles and postseason success. While Romo certainly possesses the skill set to guide a team to a championship, the fact that he hasn't been able to get the Cowboys over the hump prevents me from placing him above Manning.

The reigning Super Bowl MVP has emerged as one of the league's best quarterbacks in the clutch, and his ability to win big games earns him the nod, despite the disparity in talent. Plus, one offensive trend, one defensive tactic and two intriguing quarterback prospects. Is Eli Manning or Tony Romo the more superior quarterback? Published: May 22, at AM. Bucky Brooks NFL. How do you measure a quarterback's greatness: wins or production?

Arm talent. Jeremiah: QBs for every occasion. Advantage: Romo. Game management. I just don't think At different times in your career you're asked to do that, and you could Romo said the Giants' struggles stem from a lack of depth around Manning, and the fact that the team is overmatched right now.

It just requires a little more of them. Manning's average time to throw was 2. Odell Beckham Jr. When Cutler called attention to Peyton's solo cup, the older Manning bro had the perfect enigmatic reply:.

Skip to main content Skip to navigation. Green Bay Packers. Las Vegas Raiders. Saints rule out Kamara, Armstead vs. New Orleans Saints. Browns rule out Chubb; Johnson to start vs. Cleveland Browns. QB Newton 'still floating' over return to Panthers. Carolina Panthers.

Love ready, but Packers expecting Rodgers back. Bills TE Knox to return from broken hand vs. Buffalo Bills. Broncos OC Shurmur likely out vs.